There Is Much More to Mindfulness Than the Popular Media Hype

There Is Much More to Mindfulness Than the Popular Media Hype

By Pierce Salguero, Penn State

Mindfulness is seemingly all over the place as of late. A Google search I carried out in January 2022 for the time period “mindfulness” resulted in nearly 3 billion hits. The observe is now routinely supplied in workplaces, faculties, psychologists’ workplaces and hospitals all throughout the nation.

Most of the general public enthusiasm for mindfulness stems from the popularity it has for decreasing stress. But students and researchers who work on mindfulness, and the Buddhist custom itself, paint a extra advanced image than does the favored media.

Medicalizing meditation

Mindfulness originated within the Buddhist observe of “anapana-sati,” a Sanskrit phrase which means “awareness of breath.” Buddhist historian Erik Braun has traced the origins of the contemporary popularity of meditation to colonial Burma – modern-day Myanmar – within the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Meditation, which was practiced nearly completely inside monasteries till then, was launched to most of the people in a simplified format that was simpler to study.

The gradual unfold of meditation from that point to the current is a surprisingly advanced story.

In the U.S., meditation first began to be practiced amongst diverse communities of spiritual seekers as early because the nineteenth century. It was adopted by professional psychotherapists within the early twentieth century. By the twenty first century, it had turn out to be a mass-marketing phenomenon promoted by celebrities comparable to Oprah Winfrey, Deepak Chopra and Gwyneth Paltrow.

The technique of translating the Buddhist observe of meditation throughout cultural divides reworked the observe in important methods. Modern meditation usually has completely different targets and priorities than conventional Buddhist meditation. It tends to give attention to stress discount, psychological health or concrete advantages in each day life as a substitute of non secular growth, liberation or enlightenment.

A pivotal second on this transformation was the creation of the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) protocol by Jon Kabat-Zinn, a professor of drugs on the University of Massachusetts Medical School, in 1979. The stress discount program launched a standardized method of instructing meditation to sufferers in order that its health advantages might be extra rigorously measured by scientists.

Research on this new type of “medicalized” mindfulness started to collect steam prior to now twenty years. As of immediately there are over 21,000 analysis articles on mindfulness within the National Library of Medicine’s online database — two and a half occasions as many articles as have been printed on yoga, tai chi and reiki mixed.

Scientific proof vs. mindfulness hype

Happy young woman sitting in yoga position

Medical researchers themselves have had a much more measured opinion about the advantages of meditation than the favored press.

For instance, a 2019 meta-analysis, which is a evaluation of many particular person scientific research, pointed out that the proof for the advantages of mindfulness and different meditation-based interventions has “significant limitations” and that the analysis has “methodological shortcomings.”

Based on their evaluation of the scientific literature, the authors warned in opposition to falling prey to “mindfulness hype.” On the constructive facet, they discovered varied types of meditation to be kind of akin to the standard therapies at the moment used to deal with melancholy, anxiousness, continual ache and substance use. On the opposite hand, they concluded that extra proof is required earlier than any robust claims may be made relating to remedy of circumstances comparable to consideration issues, PTSD, dysregulated consuming or critical psychological sicknesses.

More troubling, some researchers are even starting to recommend {that a} sure proportion of sufferers could expertise negative side effects from the observe of meditation, together with elevated anxiousness, melancholy or, in excessive circumstances, even psychosis. While the causes of those negative effects will not be but absolutely understood, it’s evident that for some sufferers, therapeutic meditation is much from the panacea it’s usually made out to be.

Putting mindfulness again into context

Body, mind, soul, spirit stock photo

As a historian of the relationship between Buddhism and medicine, I argue that mindfulness could be a helpful observe for many individuals, however that we should always perceive the broader context wherein it developed and has been practiced for hundreds of years. Mindfulness is one small a part of a various vary of therapeutic methods and views the Buddhist custom has developed and maintained over many centuries.

In a current e book, I have traced the global history of the various ways in which the faith has contributed to the event of drugs over the previous 2,400 years or so. Buddhist custom advocates numerous contemplations, devotional practices, natural treatments, dietary recommendation and methods of synchronizing the human physique with the atmosphere and the seasons, all of that are associated to therapeutic.

These concepts and practices are enormously influential around the world in addition to in Buddhist communities in the U.S. Such interventions have been particularly visible during the COVID-19 pandemic – for instance, via the medical charity of main worldwide Buddhist organizations in addition to via health recommendation given by high-profile monastics such because the Dalai Lama.

Buddhism has all the time had quite a bit to say about health. But maybe probably the most important of its many contributions is its instructing that our bodily and psychological well-being are intricately intertwined – not solely with one another, but additionally with the health and vitality of all residing beings.

Medicalized meditation is now a self-help commodity that generates over US$1 billion per yr, main some critics to label it “McMindfulness.” But inserting mindfulness again right into a Buddhist moral context exhibits that it isn’t sufficient to easily meditate to scale back our personal stress or to extra successfully navigate the challenges of the trendy world.

As I argue in my most recent book, Buddhist ethics asks us to search for from our meditation cushions and to look out past our particular person selves. It asks us to understand how every thing is interconnected and the way our actions and decisions affect our lives, our society and the atmosphere. The emphasis, even whereas therapeutic ourselves, is all the time on turning into brokers of compassion, therapeutic and well-being for the entire.

[This Week in Religion, a global roundup each Thursday. Sign up.]The Conversation

Pierce Salguero, Associate Professor of Asian History & Religious Studies, Penn State

This article is republished from The Conversation beneath a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.